Skip to main content

India's Failed Demonetization Program and Its Retreating Economic Defenders - Alt-M

xxx

The accumulating evidence on economic growth, meanwhile, has become damning. Between July and September 2016, India’s GDP grew 7.53 percent. Between January and March 2017 it grew 5.72 percent. Former head of the Reserve Bank of India Raghuram Rajan, now returned to the University of Chicago, links the drop to demonetization: “Let us not mince words about it — GDP has suffered. The estimates I have seen range from 1 to 2 percentage points, and that's a lot of money — over Rs2 lakh crore [i.e. trillion] and maybe approaching Rs2.5 lakh crore." Kaul adds that GDP does not well capture the size of the informal cash sector, where the losses from demonetization were greatest.

From India's Failed Demonetization Program and Its Retreating Economic Defenders - Alt-M

So why does the Bank of England think that getting rid of paper cash will boost the economy when the figures from India clearly show it didn’t. The answer, of course, relates to the stage of development of the economy. In England, there are ready alternatives to cash that almost everyone already uses. Contactless cards and mobile phones mean that if all the ATMs in England gave up the ghost tomorrow, it wouldn’t really matter. Yes, there are some unbanked people and, as I have long argued, we should be providing digital financial services that are appropriate to them (not forcing them to use bank accounts) so that they can use electronic alternatives. Having been involved in projects to do just this (e.g., mobile money accounts for “universal credit” recipients and services delivered via digital TV to the housebound) I can honestly say that I do not find insurmountable problems.

While the India has taken great strides (the introduction of “payment banks”) 

xxx

"‘There were a lot of people who came and clicked photos (of the sign) but apart from that no transactions,’"

Bitcoin accepted here: The tiny family restaurant in India that's embraced virtual currency — Quartz

xxx

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Euro area card payments double in a decade

xxx "The number of card payments in the euro area have more than doubled in a decade as consumers increasingly dispense with the hassle of carrying notes and coins, according to the latest statistics from the European Central Bank. In 2018, card payments accounted for almost half of the total number of non-cash payments across the single-currency area. Credit transfers and direct debits were the second and third most common non-cash payment methods, accounting for approximately 23% each, while e-money and cheques together made up around seven percent. However, the relative popularity of each type of payment service still varies widely across euro area countries. In 2018 card payments accounted for just over 70% of all non‑cash payments in Portugal, compared with around 23% in Germany. The stats show that the number of card payments made by consumers and businesses has more than doubled in the last decade, with an average of 121 card payments per capita in 2018, compared with